21 October 2009            Cigarette packet displays at point of sale                          

29 September 2008 Parliament’s Health Committee recommends a ban

Parliament’s Health Select Committee by majority vote recommends to Parliament that cigarettes and tobacco products be put out of sight. Four National Party MPs (including two medical practitioners) opposed the Committee’s recommendation. 

 http://www.endsmoking.org.nz/TobDisplays_HealthComm.pdf   The basis of National’s dissenting opinion, on the grounds of insufficient international evidence, means they might support it if the evidence increased. 

This recommendation required legislation, which Government did not have sufficient time to pass in 2008. Meantime, the graphic health warnings, introduced in 2008 will be on open display for a few years yet.

 

Conclusion

  • A Select Committee recommendation usually results in a law change within a few years.
  • Point-of-sale displays make first purchases easier, and trigger unpremeditated repeat sales, and will likely facilitate relapse.  
  • Cigarette display bans will assist in reducing cigarette sales and cigarette smoking prevalence.
  • A ban on cigarette packet displays is a step towards ending all sales of cigarettes.                    
  • Ending all sales of cigarettes and smoking tobacco will drastically reduce the numbers who smoke.

 

 

Tobacco display ban laws passed:

Jurisdiction, as of 21 Oct 2009

With effect from

Iceland

2001

Canada, all of

2002-2010

Thailand

2005

British Virgin Islands

2007

Ireland

2009

England Wales and Northern Ireland

2010-2011

Australian Capital Territory, NSW, Victoria, WA, Tasmania

2010-2013

Scotland

In progress

Sweden

In progress

 

 

Position of End Smoking NZ

End Smoking supports such a ban on display of all smoking tobacco and cigarettes at point of sale.

For NZ research on this topic see www.wnmeds.ac.nz under Wilson N. and www.ash.org.nz under Paynter J.

  Bottom line: Will this policy reduce numbers smoking, and consumption? Yes it will..

 Dr Murray Laugesen QSO chair; Prof Ross McCormick, Sir John Scott KBE, Trish Fraser MPH, Dr Marewa Glover, Trustees

Out of sight, out of mind, making it easier for whole countries to quit smoking  © 2009 End Smoking NZ